THE EVOLUTION OF PHYSICIAN-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP: FROM INFORMATION TO COUNSELLING

Amalia Diurni

Abstract


The physician-patient relationship has changed over time: in the nineteenth century it was characterised by professional
dominance; in the twentieth century a unilateral aleatory contract came into being between the professional and his client;
it is expected that in the future medical practice will come to be based on individual genetic predisposition, where
treatment will precede early symptoms and illnesses will be treated with personalised remedies and medicines. Until now,
government policies have mainly aimed at safeguarding patients’ health; today evermore attention is being paid to
patients’ right to self-determination. Society’s perception of the physician has also changed: the physician is no longer seen
as the custodian of an absolute knowledge, but rather as a service provider and the patient has come to be seen as a
consumer.Over the last decades patients’ protection has seen the rule of informed consent and efforts to favour patients
under the law. Europe now fears that this favouritism will eventually trigger a crisis similar to the one which
overwhelmed the U.S.A: in the U.S. the consequence was the halting of the lay standard in favour of the professional
one; in Europe a defensive practice has come into being. This practice is based on complex risk management procedures
and strict protocols consisting of many forms and very detailed information leaflets. Today, these two aspects - the
preference of patients’ right to self-determination and defensive practices - are the main reasons behind the physicianpatient
relationship transformation. Traditional one-way physician-patient communication is being replaced by dialogue.
The move is one from information to counselling. The paternalistic approach of traditional medicine has already been
replaced by the principle of physician-patient cooperation, which is a prelude to modern “talking medicine”. This paper
focuses on describing this medical approach change and the juridical and practical implications that come with it.

Full Text:

PDF (Italiano)

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Department of Law - University of Perugia
Via Pascoli, 33 - 06123 Perugia (PG) -  Telephone 075.5852401 
Comparative Law Review is registered at the Courthouse of Monza (Italy) - Nr. 1988 - May, 10th 2010.
Editors - Prof. Giovanni Marini, Prof. Pier Giuseppe Monateri, Prof. Tommaso Edoardo Frosini, Prof. Salvatore Sica, Prof. Alessandro Somma, Prof. Giuseppe Franco Ferrari, Prof. Massimiliano Granieri.

Direttore responsabile:Alessandro Somma